Skip to content

Residential

Roof replacement

Everything comes off, down to the wood. Then the roof goes back on in layers, and each layer is there for a reason. This is the whole job, in the order we do it.

Roofer nailing a new course of architectural shingles over gray synthetic underlayment

What's under the shingles

The shingles shed most of the water. The layers under them deal with what gets past, and the flashing deals with every place the roof is interrupted. A roof that leaks young usually has a layer missing or done cheaply, not a bad shingle.

Section at the eave · not to scale
Cross-section of a shingle roof from the eave to the ridge: rafters, roof deck, drip edge, ice-and-water shield, synthetic underlayment, starter course, shingles, a pipe boot and a ridge vent, with attic air drawn in at the soffit and out at the ridge. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Shingles cut back part way up the slope to show the layers beneath. The dashed line is attic air, in at the soffit and out at the ridge.
  1. Roof deck

    The plywood or OSB sheathing nailed to the rafters. Everything above is fastened to it, so soft or delaminated sheets are replaced, never covered over.

  2. Drip edge

    Bent metal along the eaves and rakes. It carries water past the fascia and into the gutter instead of letting it wick back into the wood.

  3. Ice-and-water shield

    Self-adhering membrane at the eaves, in the valleys and around every penetration. It seals around each nail, which is what stops water that gets pushed back up under the shingles.

  4. Synthetic underlayment

    Covers the rest of the deck, lapped over the ice-and-water shield. Tougher than the old felt paper, and it keeps the house dry while the shingles go on.

  5. Starter course

    An adhesive strip along the eaves and rakes, so the first course and the roof edges are sealed down against wind.

  6. Shingles

    Nailed where the manufacturer's instructions put the nails, at the exposure they call for. The wind rating depends on it.

  7. Flashing and pipe boots

    Metal and rubber at every place the roof is interrupted: pipes, chimneys, walls, skylights. It is where most leaks start.

  8. Ridge vent

    A continuous opening along the peak under a vented cap, where warm, damp attic air leaves.

  9. Attic airflow

    Air comes in at the soffit vents and out at the ridge. In a wet climate, that draft is what keeps condensation off the underside of the deck.

Twelve steps

The job, start to finish

Every roof we replace goes through the same sequence. The order matters: each layer laps over the one before it, the way water runs downhill.

  1. Estimate and deck assessment

    We walk the roof, look in the attic if there's a hatch, and count how many layers are on. Soft spots underfoot, sags between rafters and stained sheathing tell us how much deck may need work before anything comes off. You get the estimate in writing, itemized.

  2. Tear-off to the deck

    Tarps go down over beds and along the walls first. Then the old shingles, underlayment and nails come off, down to bare wood, straight into the trailer or bin. A new roof laid over an old one hides the deck and wears out sooner, so everything comes off.

  3. Deck repair and re-sheathing

    Soft, rotted or delaminated sheets are cut out and replaced. Older houses with board decking and wide gaps between the boards may need new sheathing over the whole roof. We show you what we found before we replace it.

  4. Drip edge

    Metal along the eaves goes on first, under the membrane. The rakes get theirs after the underlayment, over it. Each piece laps the way water runs.

  5. Ice-and-water shield

    Along the eaves, up every valley and around chimneys, skylights and pipes: the places where water slows down, collects or gets driven sideways by wind.

  6. Synthetic underlayment

    Across the rest of the deck, lapped over the shield and fastened on the manufacturer's schedule. From here the house is dried in, so a rain shower between steps doesn't reach the attic.

  7. Starter course

    Along the eaves and up the rakes, so the first row of shingles and the roof edges have a sealed strip under them.

  8. Flashing

    Step flashing woven in with each course where the roof meets a wall. Counter-flashing let into the chimney's mortar joints and lapped over the step flashing. New pipe boots and vent flashing at every penetration. It is where roofs leak, so it's replaced rather than patched around.

  9. Shingles

    Courses snapped to chalk lines and kept straight, nails where the wrapper says, valleys cut clean, hips and ridge capped.

  10. Ridge vent and attic ventilation

    A continuous vent along the ridge, balanced against the intake at the soffits. If the attic doesn't have enough intake, we'll tell you, because a ridge vent with no air coming in at the bottom doesn't move much air.

  11. Cleanup and magnetic nail sweep

    Debris to the trailer, gutters flushed of grit and stray nails, then a rolling magnet over the lawn, beds, driveway and the street edge.

  12. Final walk-through

    We walk the job with you and go over what we found under the old roof, what we replaced and why, with photos of anything you couldn't see from the ground.

What to expect on the day

A tear-off is loud, busy and fast. Here's what it looks like from inside the house, and what makes it easier.

1–3
Days for a typical house

A simple single-story roof can be one long day. Steep pitches, a roof cut up by dormers and valleys, a second layer coming off or a lot of deck repair all add time, and so does rain. We only open up as much roof as can be dried in the same day.

  • Noise

    Hammers and nail guns overhead for most of the day. If you work from home, plan to work somewhere else for the tear-off.

  • Driveway

    We need it for the trailer and the materials. Park on the street the night before, and take the car out of the garage if the driveway is the only way out.

  • Pets and kids

    The noise upsets most dogs and cats; a quiet room at the other end of the house, or a day away, helps. Keep everyone clear of the drip line, where debris comes down.

  • Walls and attic

    Hammering shakes the top floor. Take down mirrors and framed pictures up there. Anything stored in the attic will collect dust and grit, so cover it or move it.

  • Yard

    Point out sprinkler heads, a fragile plant or a spot you'd rather the trailer didn't sit. It's easier before the tarps go down.

Choosing the shingle

On a house, the choice is usually between 3-tab and architectural shingle. The layers under them are the same either way; the difference is weight, wind resistance, looks and how long they last.

Shingles need enough pitch to shed water. A near-flat porch roof or a low addition gets single-ply membrane (TPO or PVC) instead, flashed into the shingles where the two meet.

Compare materials
3-tab and architectural shingle compared
Feature 3-tab asphalt shingle Architectural shingle
Construction One flat layer with cutouts that make three tabs Two layers laminated together, thicker and heavier
Look Flat and uniform, even slots Shadowed and dimensional; reads like shake from the street
Wind Lower wind ratings Higher wind ratings; the weight helps it stay down
Typical life 15–20 years 25–30 years
Where it fits Garages, sheds and outbuildings; the tightest budgets Most houses, especially if you plan to stay

Lifespans are typical industry ranges with proper installation and upkeep, not a promise about any one roof. Moss, shade and ventilation all move the number.

Signs it's time

One of these on one slope may be a repair. Several of them, across the roof, usually aren't.

  • It's old for what it is: 3-tab past about 15–20 years, architectural past 25 or so.
  • Granules collecting in the gutters and at the downspout, and dark, bare patches on the shingles.
  • Edges curling up or cupping, or shingles gone brittle enough to crack when they're lifted.
  • Leaks in more than one place, or the same leak back after a repair.
  • Decking that feels soft or springy underfoot, or a roofline that dips between rafters.
  • Years of moss grown in under the shingle edges and lifting them.
  • Dark staining on the underside of the deck in the attic, or daylight between the boards.

Not sure which side of the line you're on? Start with roof repair, or read the repair-or-replace guide. If a repair buys you real years, we'll say so.

Worn 3-tab shingles with cracked, split and buckled tabs across the slope
Cracks and splits running across many courses, not one. That's a roof wearing out, not a repair. Photo: Samuel Bolton, CC BY-SA 4.0.
Free estimate

Get a replacement estimate

We'll walk the roof, look in the attic and count the layers, then write down exactly what the job includes. Free, and no pressure to decide on the spot.